Country and Territory Protection List

From Wikimedia Foundation Governance Wiki
Revision as of 00:19, 23 January 2024 by FuzzyBot (talk | contribs) (Updating to match new version of source page)

Transparency is a cornerstone of the Wikimedia movement — as such, we care a lot about what data we release and how we release it. In line with our Data Publication Guidelines, our goal is to provide accurate information about our projects without exacerbating the privacy and other safety risks that our communities may face for contributing to our projects.

The Country and Territory Protection List Policy aims to enhance the Wikimedia Foundation's ability to publish information and protect contributors' personal information, while preserving everyone's ability to contribute safely to our projects online, consistent with the Foundation's commitment to upholding Wikimedians' rights to privacy as laid out in its Human Rights Policy. Publishing exact values of high-level, seemingly anonymous statistics exposes contributors to or risks. To that end, this update of the Country and Territory Protection List Policy takes into account the ability of to statistically mask individual contributors and contributions. This update will allow for more flexibility and nuance without compromising the safety of our communities, and will thus allow us to release more data and better meet communities' needs.

Process

The Wikimedia Foundation relies on the judgments of respected international human rights NGOs to assess potential risk to Wikimedia users. Every year, Reporters Without Borders produces an annual score for hundreds of countries and territories (based on a review of political, economic, legislative, social, and security factors) that signifies journalistic safety in each place. Similarly, Freedom House produces an annual internet freedom score for nearly 80 countries and territories (based on a questionnaire that evaluates obstacles to access, limits on content, and violations of user rights).

These signals are highly-credible and dynamic, with updates every year provided by panels of subject matter experts. Relying on this independent data allows our own models to iterate and provides every person with access to sensitive data with a built-in set of guidelines around risk minimization. They also give the Wikimedia Foundation a sense of the relative risk of government or other parties' actions against Wikimedia community members for their on-platform behaviors (e.g. editing and reading). Where possible, we average the two scores together and subtract them from 100 to get a composite risk score, where 0 is the least likely and 100 is the most likely to take action against community members for on-platform behavior.

[1]

Based on the composite score, we then sort each country or territory into one of four categories:

  • 0 to 60 — lower risk: These countries and territories are at lower risk of action being taken against Wikimedia community members for on-platform activities. The Wikimedia Foundation can publish aggregated data about them as long as it is in line with the minimum thresholds set out in the Data Publication Guidelines.
  • 60 to 67.5 — medium risk: These countries and territories are at medium risk of action being taken against Wikimedia community members for on-platform activities. The Wikimedia Foundation can publish aggregated data about them only using differential privacy such that any consumer of the data will be (in the worst case) at most 5% more certain about a data subject's presence or absence in the dataset.[2]
  • 67.5 to 75 — higher risk: These countries and territories are at higher risk of action being taken against Wikimedia community members for on-platform activities. The Wikimedia Foundation can publish aggregated data about them only using differential privacy such that any consumer of the data will be (in the worst case) at most 2.5% more certain about a data subject's presence or absence in the dataset.[3]

75 to 100 — not published: These countries and territories are at the highest risk of action being taken against Wikimedia community members for on-platform activities. For reasons of user and editor safety, the Wikimedia Foundation does not publish aggregated data about them.

Some countries and territories are not included in the Country and Territory Protection List because they do not have sufficient associated scores from our data sources; in these cases, privacy and human rights experts may decide their risk category.

Country and territory protection list designations

In 2024, the country and territory protection list is as follows:

Medium risk

There are twenty countries and territories deemed medium risk of action being taken against community members for on-platform activities: Afghanistan, Azerbaijan, Bangladesh, Djibouti, Ethiopia, Honduras, Iraq, Kazakhstan, Kuwait, Laos, Nicaragua, Oman, Pakistan, Palestine, Sudan, Tajikistan, United Arab Emirates, Uzbekistan, Venezuela, and Yemen.

Higher risk

There are eight countries and territories deemed higher risk of action being taken against community members for on-platform activities: Bahrain, Belarus, Egypt, Eritrea, Russia, Saudi Arabia, Türkiye, and Turkmenistan.

Not published

There are eight countries and territories deemed highest risk of action being taken against community members for on-platform activities, and that are, as a result, too risky to publish data about: China, Cuba, Iran, Macau, Myanmar, North Korea, Syria, and Vietnam.

Full country and territory list

Country and territory protection list (full list)
Country Score Protected? (Yes/No) Risk Designation
Афганистан 60.25 Да Medium risk
Албания 42.14 Нет Lower risk
Алжир 54.26 Нет Lower risk
Андорра 24.95 Нет Lower risk
Ангола 46.35 Нет Lower risk
Ангилья (OECS) 41.64 Нет Lower risk
Антигуа и Барбуда (OECS) 41.64 Нет Lower risk
Аргентина 26.82 Нет Lower risk
Армения 28.70 Нет Lower risk
Австралия 22.88 Нет Lower risk
Австрия 22.70 Нет Lower risk
Азербайджан 61.54 Да Medium risk
Бахрейн 70.71 Да Higher risk
Бангладеш 61.85 Да Medium risk
Белоруссия 68.92 Да Higher risk
Бельгия 23.53 Нет Lower risk
Белиз 29.51 Нет Lower risk
Бенин 47.56 Нет Lower risk
Бутан 40.75 Нет Lower risk
Боливия 48.91 Нет Lower risk
Босния и Герцеговина 34.57 Нет Lower risk
Ботсвана 35.39 Нет Lower risk
Бразилия 38.67 Нет Lower risk
Британские Виргинские острова (OECS) 41.64 Нет Lower risk
Бруней-Даруссалам 55.80 Нет Lower risk
Болгария 37.02 Нет Lower risk
Буркина-Фасо 32.36 Нет Lower risk
Бурунди 47.86 Нет Lower risk
Кабо-Верде 24.28 Нет Lower risk
Камбоджа 56.99 Нет Lower risk
Камерун 54.42 Нет Lower risk
Канада 14.24 Нет Lower risk
Центральноафриканская Республика 42.44 Нет Lower risk
Чад 46.27 Нет Lower risk
Чили 39.91 Нет Lower risk
Китай 84.02 Да Not published
Колумбия 44.89 Нет Lower risk
Коморы 37.75 Нет Lower risk
Республика Конго 39.58 Нет Lower risk
Коста-Рика 17.40 Нет Lower risk
Кот-д’Ивуар 31.17 Нет Lower risk
Хорватия 28.05 Нет Lower risk
Куба 75.50 Да Not published
Кипр 31.38 Нет Lower risk
Чехия 16.42 Нет Lower risk
Дания 10.52 Нет Lower risk
Джибути 64.13 Да Medium risk
Доминика (OECS) 41.64 Нет Lower risk
Доминиканская Республика 28.12 Нет Lower risk
Демократическая Республика Конго 51.45 Нет Lower risk
Восточный Тимор 15.51 Нет Lower risk
Эквадор 37.75 Нет Lower risk
Египет 69.32 Да Higher risk
Сальвадор 48.64 Нет Lower risk
Экваториальная Гвинея 49.65 Нет Lower risk
Эритрея 72.14 Да Higher risk
Эстония 10.85 Нет Lower risk
Эсватини 47.34 Нет Lower risk
Эфиопия 63.15 Да Medium risk
Фиджи 40.73 Нет Lower risk
Финляндия 12.06 Нет Lower risk
Франция 22.64 Нет Lower risk
Габон 41.88 Нет Lower risk
Гамбия 36.47 Нет Lower risk
Грузия 31.16 Нет Lower risk
Германия 20.55 Нет Lower risk
Гана 34.54 Нет Lower risk
Греция 44.80 Нет Lower risk
Гренада (OECS) 41.64 Нет Lower risk
Гваделупа (OECS) 41.64 Нет Lower risk
Гватемала 51.88 Нет Lower risk
Гвинея 40.49 Нет Lower risk
Гвинея-Бисау 38.43 Нет Lower risk
Гайана 32.50 Нет Lower risk
Гаити 42.62 Нет Lower risk
Гондурас 67.35 Да Medium risk
Гонконг 55.14 Нет Lower risk
Венгрия 34.02 Нет Lower risk
Исландия 11.41 Нет Lower risk
Индия 56.69 Нет Lower risk
Индонезия 49.09 Нет Lower risk
Иран 82.10 Да Not published
Ирак 62.03 Да Medium risk
Ирландия 10.09 Нет Lower risk
Израиль 42.43 Нет Lower risk
Италия 26.48 Нет Lower risk
Ямайка 24.11 Нет Lower risk
Япония 29.53 Нет Lower risk
Иордания 55.11 Нет Lower risk
Казахстан 60.07 Да Medium risk
Кения 41.43 Нет Lower risk
Республика Косово 31.62 Нет Lower risk
Кувейт 61.16 Да Medium risk
Кыргызстан 49.05 Нет Lower risk
Лаос 63.34 Да Medium risk
Латвия 16.73 Нет Lower risk
Ливан 49.77 Нет Lower risk
Лесото 35.71 Нет Lower risk
Либерия 35.66 Нет Lower risk
Ливия 58.89 Нет Lower risk
Лихтенштейн 15.53 Нет Lower risk
Литва 13.21 Нет Lower risk
Люксембург 18.02 Нет Lower risk
Макао n/a Да Not published
Мадагаскар 43.34 Нет Lower risk
Малави 39.83 Нет Lower risk
Малайзия 38.09 Нет Lower risk
Мальдивы 43.07 Нет Lower risk
Мали 47.71 Нет Lower risk
Мальта 40.24 Нет Lower risk
Мартиника (OECS) 41.64 Нет Lower risk
Мавритания 40.55 Нет Lower risk
Маврикий 34.44 Нет Lower risk
Мексика 45.01 Нет Lower risk
Молдавия 22.38 Нет Lower risk
Монголия 40.67 Нет Lower risk
Черногория 25.72 Нет Lower risk
Монтсеррат (OECS) 41.64 Нет Lower risk
Марокко 51.66 Нет Lower risk
Мозамбик 43.87 Нет Lower risk
Мьянма 80.87 Да Not published
Намибия 19.09 Нет Lower risk
Непал 42.11 Нет Lower risk
Нидерланды 13.00 Нет Lower risk
Новая Зеландия 15.77 Нет Lower risk
Никарагуа 60.46 Да Medium risk
Нигер 33.16 Нет Lower risk
Нигерия 45.22 Нет Lower risk
КНДР 78.28 Да Not published
Северная Македония 25.65 Нет Lower risk
Норвегия 4.82 Нет Lower risk
Оман 62.13 Да Medium risk
Пакистан 67.03 Да Medium risk
Государство Палестина 62.14 Да Medium risk
Панама 36.33 Нет Lower risk
Папуа — Новая Гвинея 32.38 Нет Lower risk
Парагвай 44.04 Нет Lower risk
Перу 47.26 Нет Lower risk
Филиппины 46.40 Нет Lower risk
Польша 32.34 Нет Lower risk
Португалия 15.40 Нет Lower risk
Катар 44.72 Нет Lower risk
Румыния 30.96 Нет Lower risk
Россия 72.12 Да Higher risk
Руанда 58.21 Нет Lower risk
Сент-Китс и Невис (OECS) 41.64 Нет Lower risk
Сент-Люсия (OECS) 41.64 Нет Lower risk
Сент-Винсент и Гренадины (OECS) 41.64 Нет Lower risk
Самоа 17.85 Нет Lower risk
Саудовская Аравия 71.29 Да Higher risk
Сенегал 44.18 Нет Lower risk
Сербия 34.92 Нет Lower risk
Сейшельские Острова 24.29 Нет Lower risk
Сьерра-Леоне 37.45 Нет Lower risk
Сингапур 49.06 Нет Lower risk
Словакия 16.78 Нет Lower risk
Словения 29.41 Нет Lower risk
Сомали 55.76 Нет Lower risk
ЮАР 24.20 Нет Lower risk
Республика Корея 31.09 Нет Lower risk
Южный Судан 49.38 Нет Lower risk
Испания 24.63 Нет Lower risk
Шри-Ланка 51.08 Нет Lower risk
Судан 64.59 Да Medium risk
Суринам 29.38 Нет Lower risk
Швеция 11.85 Нет Lower risk
Швейцария 15.60 Нет Lower risk
Сирия 77.89 Да Not published
Тайвань 23.23 Нет Lower risk
Таджикистан 60.94 Да Medium risk
Танзания 55.98 Нет Lower risk
Таиланд 52.88 Нет Lower risk
Того 36.94 Нет Lower risk
Тонга 28.71 Нет Lower risk
Тринидад и Тобаго 23.46 Нет Lower risk
Тунис 45.45 Нет Lower risk
Турция 68.02 Да Higher risk
Туркменистан 74.18 Да Higher risk
Уганда 51.46 Нет Lower risk
Украина 39.91 Нет Lower risk
Объединённые Арабские Эмираты 63.51 Да Medium risk
Великобритания 21.25 Нет Lower risk
США 26.39 Нет Lower risk
Уругвай 29.67 Нет Lower risk
Узбекистан 64.64 Да Medium risk
Венесуэла 67.01 Да Medium risk
Вьетнам 76.71 Да Not published
Западная Сахара 51.66 Нет Lower risk
Йемен 67.22 Да Medium risk
Замбия 40.80 Нет Lower risk
Зимбабве 50.42 Нет Lower risk

Примечания

  1. Where there are not two scores, we fall back to using the single score we have from one of the NGOs.
  2. This corresponds to a privacy loss (epsilon value) ≤ 0.2 for a data release.
  3. This corresponds to a privacy loss (epsilon value) ≤ 0.1 for a data release.