News

Victory in Italy: Wikimedia wins lawsuit against former Minister of Defense

Photo by Andreas Tille, CC BY-SA 4.0.

Today, we are happy to announce that on Feb. 19, 2018, the Court of Appeals of Rome ruled in favor of the Wikimedia Foundation in Previti v. Wikimedia Foundation. This ruling protects the community editing model and enables the work of all the volunteers in the Wikimedia movement.

In 2012, Cesare Previti, a former Italian Minister of Defense, sued the Wikimedia Foundation for hosting a Wikipedia article he alleged contained defamatory information. Mr. Previti sent a general letter demanding that the article be deleted without clearly identifying what content was defamatory or a link to where it was hosted, and subsequently filed the suit requesting its removal when the Wikimedia Foundation did not take it down.

In 2013, the Civil Court in Rome ruled in our favor. The court held that as a hosting provider, the Wikimedia Foundation cannot be held liable for the content of Wikipedia articles, which it does not control. The court also noted that both the Foundation and the Wikipedia sites themselves provide information about the open and collaborative nature of the encyclopedia.

Mr. Previti appealed the decision, claiming that the Foundation did not just host information created by third parties, but also actively participated in the creation and management of content. The Court of Appeals of Rome has now affirmed the lower court’s decision.

In a ruling that provides strong protection for Wikipedia’s community governance model, the Court once again recognized that the Wikimedia Foundation is a hosting provider, and that the volunteer editors and contributors create and control content on the Wikimedia projects. The Court also made clear that a general warning letter, without additional detail about the online location, unlawfulness, or the harmful nature of the content as recognized by a court, does not impose a removal obligation on a hosting provider like the Wikimedia Foundation.

Finally, the Court took notice of Wikipedia’s unique model of community-based content creation, and the mechanisms by which someone can suggest edits or additions to project content. It found that Wikipedia has a clear community procedure for content modification, which Mr. Previti should have used to address his concerns. He could have reached out to the volunteer editors, provided reliable sources, and suggested amendments to the article,  instead of sending a general warning letter to the Foundation.

As a result of the court’s ruling, the article will remain on the projects, and Mr. Previti will pay the Wikimedia Foundation some of the expenses incurred in defending the lawsuit and appeal.

This ruling is a victory not just for the Foundation, or editors of Italian Wikipedia, but for Wikimedians everywhere, and their ability to make accurate, well-sourced information freely available. Wikipedia is created, edited, supported, and managed by its global community of volunteer editors, contributors, and translators. The Wikimedia Foundation’s status as a hosting provider allows it to provide a platform for these volunteers to share their work with the entire world in nearly three hundred different languages. Decisions like this one, which recognize and reaffirm that status, are important for the growth of open source communities in general, and especially the future dissemination of free knowledge on the Wikimedia projects.

Jacob Rogers, Legal Counsel
Emine Yildirim, Legal Fellow

The Foundation would like to extend special thanks to Marco Berliri and his team at Hogan Lovells, who assisted us with their excellent representation throughout this case.

 

Related

Read further in the pursuit of knowledge

Wikimedia Foundation Earns Accreditation to the United Nations Economic and Social Affairs Council (ECOSOC)

Through a historic vote on 21 July 2022, the Wikimedia Foundation was granted accreditation by the United Nations Economic and Social Affairs Council (ECOSOC). The Foundation  thanks the cosponsors of the corresponding resolution that was proposed by the United States, Italy, Sweden, and Estonia earlier this week, and all the ECOSOC members who voted for it. ….

Read more

Wikimedia Foundation welcomes strong support for accreditation to UN ECOSOC

The Wikimedia Foundation welcomes yesterday’s decision of the United States, Italy, Sweden, and Estonia to introduce, with broad cross-regional support from other member states, a resolution asking the UN’s Economic and Social Affairs Council (ECOSOC) to grant accreditation to the Wikimedia Foundation and five other NGOs: Inimõiguste Instituut (Estonia), Syrian American Medical Society (US), National….

Read more

Wikimedia Foundation becomes official EQUALS Global Partner

We are pleased to announce we are now an EQUALS Global Partner, joining a growing network of companies, foundations, academia, United Nations agencies and civil society organizations who are coming together to bridge the digital gender divide for more women

Read more

Help us unlock the world’s knowledge.

As a nonprofit, Wikipedia and our related free knowledge projects are powered primarily through donations.

Donate now

Connect Связь

Stay up-to-date on our work.

Get email updates

Subscribe to news about ongoing projects and initiatives.

This mailing list is powered by MailChimp. The Wikimedia Foundation will handle your personal information in accordance with this site’s privacy policy.

Contact a human

Questions about the Wikimedia Foundation or our projects? Get in touch with our team.
Contact

Photo credits