Wikimedia opposes government’s motion to dismiss Wikimedia v. NSA

The ACLU and Wikimedia Foundation have filed to oppose the US government's motion to dismiss our case against the NSA.

The American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU) has filed another motion on behalf of the Wikimedia Foundation and our eight co-plaintiffs in Wikimedia v. NSA. We promised to keep the community informed of the lawsuit’s progress, and today we are happy to provide another update.

Wikimedia v. NSA originally began in March, when the Wikimedia Foundation and our co-plaintiffs challenged the United States National Security Agency’s (NSA) large-scale search and seizure of internet communications known as “upstream” surveillance. This lawsuit is part of our ongoing effort to stand up for free expression and protect the privacy rights of our users around the world. In June, we filed an amended complaint in response to the Government’s motion to dismiss our case. As we explained then, motions to dismiss are a basic procedural hurdle common to most lawsuits in the United States.

Last month, as expected, the government moved to dismiss our amended complaint on “standing” grounds. In this type of motion, the government argues that the plaintiffs, including Wikimedia, have not demonstrated a harm that they can challenge in court (i.e., that they do not “have standing”). Yesterday’s filing opposed the government’s recent motion, point by point, underscoring the harm to Wikimedia and the illegality of the NSA’s dragnet surveillance, as spelled out in the amended complaint. It is the result of hard work and extensive collaboration between our excellent attorneys at the ACLU and Cooley LLP, who are representing us pro bono on this filing. The Wikimedia Foundation’s legal team and staff also provided support.

This is just the next step in a long process. The government will have a chance to reply, and then both sides will present oral arguments at a hearing in the U.S. District Court of Maryland on September 25, 2015. Regardless of the outcome, we anticipate other motions before a decision on the constitutionality of the surveillance. We will continue to work with the ACLU and Cooley to put forward the best possible case, and we are eager to have our claims heard by the Court. As before, we promise to post future updates as events unfold.

For more on this case, you can read about mass surveillance and Wikimedia on our new public policy portal or see the pleadings that have been filed to date.

Michelle Paulson, Legal Director
Geoff Brigham, General Counsel

Special thanks to all who are supporting our efforts in this matter in a variety of ways, including Patrick Toomey (ACLU), Jameel Jaffer (ACLU), Alex Abdo (ACLU), Ashley Gorski (ACLU), Aarti Reddy (Cooley), Amanda Levendowski (Cooley), Patrick Gunn (Cooley), Ben Kleine (Cooley), and the Wikimedia Foundation’s Victoria Baranetsky, Zhou Zhou, Aeryn Palmer, Jim Buatti, Oliver Keyes, Kevin Leduc, Faidon Liambotis, Andrew Otto, Dan Andreescu, Grace Gellerman, and Dario Taraborelli.

This post has been updated to clarify that Cooley LLP is representing the Wikimedia Foundation on a pro bono basis for this filing, and to change the image, which did not fall under the United States’ freedom of panorama laws.


Read further in the pursuit of knowledge

Experience some of the world’s most beautiful places with Wiki Loves Earth 2022

Think about that feeling you get when you are walking through pristine nature. Do you think it can be captured in a single photo?  The Wiki Loves Earth photography competition celebrates the world’s natural heritage, encompassing everything from small parks to massive nature reserves. It asks photographers to dive into those areas to pick out….

Read more

New Wikipedia editor features make it easy for everyone to contribute

New features on Wikipedia are making it easy for everyone to edit Wikipedia, especially those contributing to the site for the first time. Every time you read a Wikipedia article, you are reading the work of a volunteer contributor.  Nearly 300,000 people from around the world edit Wikipedia articles each month — they start new….

Read more
Kyiv's Independence Monument / victory column

Wikimedia Foundation calls for continued access to free and open knowledge as Ukraine crisis continues

Цей пост також доступний українською мовою.Этот пост также доступен на русском языке. Update: As the conflict has continued, the Wikimedia Foundation received a Russian government demand to remove content from Russian Wikipedia. You can read the latest update and our response. The Wikimedia Foundation supports a global movement of volunteers and communities around the world.….

Read more

Help us unlock the world’s knowledge.

As a nonprofit, Wikipedia and our related free knowledge projects are powered primarily through donations.

Donate now

Contact us

Questions about the Wikimedia Foundation or our projects? Get in touch with our team.

Photo credits